Settings

The page will reload to apply your changes.
Theme

ASCII Art Font

ASCII Art Menu

Original Usenet message from alt.ascii-art, 14 Sep 1998.
Re: About rendering ascii code in a .txt medium

Re: About rendering ascii code in a .txt medium

Pete Casso wrote:
> 
> Discussions on OE and Arial in parallel threads made me write this
> essay.

Pete, you are just too fond of writing essays. Stop it. :->

>...
> Please note, that only the ascii code is standardized, and that NONE
> of the typographical parameters is standardized. Since the
> typographical parameters are absolutely vital for the correct
> rendition of any ascii pic, their non-standardization is a constant
> source of debates, the most common of which is the proportional vs
> non-proportional debate.

Sorry Pete, but you're wrong, wrong, and wrong again.

First: typographical parameters are NOT `absolutely vital for the
correct rendition of any ascii pic'. The whole idea of ASCII art is that
no matter which fixed-width font, color, line-spacing etc. you use, you
will still be able to see the picture very nicely. Yes, this does
require some care on the part of ASCII artists -- good ASCII artists
know to use | instead of I and " instead of ~, for example, so that
their pictures look equally good with all fixed-width fonts. But these
matters are relatively trivial.

Second: the non-standardization of typographical parameters is NOT `a
constant source of debates'. I can't remember the last time I saw
anybody debating which fixed-width font, or color, or line spacing, or
whatever, everybody else should use. The reason is that noted above:
ASCII art is supposed to be drawn to look good no matter which
fixed-width font, size etc. are used.

Third, the choice between proportional and `non-proportional' (as you
call fixed-width) fonts is NOT a `debate'. ASCII art is art designed
with the ASCII characters in a fixed-width font. People may draw any
sort of character art with ASCII characters, but if they do not use a
fixed-width font then it is not ASCII art in the commonly accepted sense
of the term.

>...
> Another example is the default font face on aol, Arial, which allows
> for the correct transmission of ascii pics WITHIN aol. But of course,
> since Arial is a proportional font, ascii pics transmitted from aol
> to the outside world (and vice versa) will be distorted. (I refer to
> pics made from proportional and non-proportional fonts as ascii pics,
> since both are based on ascii code, albeit with different
> typographical conventions.)

Yes, well see above for my disagreement with that definition. And on the
subject of AOL, is AOL available for the Mac? If so, does it use the
Arial font, or something else (such as Geneva) which is more common on
Mac systems? If so, character art sent from a Windoze AOL user to a 
Mac AOL user (or vice versa) will be distorted. And what about the
people with newer versions of AOL who can (I think) change the font to
read their messages in ...?

>...
> Text editors built into email and newsgroup software are evolving
> towards more sophistication, e.g. more and more are defaulting to
> proportional font. This evolution is good for general use, e.g. it
> provides improved legibility (your own handwriting is proportional)
> but it is devastating for ascii pics.
> 
> Some time ago, Microsoft and working groups of the IETF (Internet
> Engineering Task Force) have therefore published recommendedations
> against the use of ascii pics on the Internet.

Microsoft's recommendation, if you remember, resulted in derision from
both Jorn Barger (the author of the original FAQ) and myself; do a
DejaNews search of alt.ascii art for `Jorn Barger AND Microsoft AND FAQ
AND technology', and see also
http://cgi.pathfinder.com/netly/article/0,2334,13735,00.html.

As for the IETF, only two IETF RFCs (2229 and 2295) mention ASCII art.
Neither of them discourage its use: one suggests ASCII art as an
acceptable method of providing images to Web browsers which cannot read
GIFs or JPEGs, and the other refers to ASCII art in database files.
Pete, please provide a citation for your claim that the IETF is
discouraging ASCII art.

>                                                But what they (and the
> ascii community) forget, is that it is EASY to protect ascii pics by
> including the above typographical parameters as part and parcel of
> the pics, say, in the form of html tags. This would also allow pics
> generated within aol to be correctly viewed in the outside world and
> vice versa ...

Wrong, and wrong, Pete. Firstly, I've said it before, and I'll say it
again: HTML is not a presentation language. It is a semantic markup
language. Good luck trying to specify the font, color, and line spacing
to someone on a monochrome monitor who doesn't have the particular font
installed. Secondly, HTML is not acceptable in the majority of Usenet
groups (I'm not just talking about a.a-a), so even if HTML was able to
do the miraculous things you claim, it would be a non-issue for a.a-a.

Pete, I love HTML even more than you seem to, but even I know what it
can't do, and where it doesn't belong. Your attempts to provide a
pseudo-academic foundation for the use of HTML tags in a.a-a (I can't
think of any other reason why you write these `essays') will not work.
ASCII art is a simple medium; learn to enjoy the simplicity, instead of
pining for extensions to it.

Regards
-- 
   .._o  Matthew Thomas (mpt26 @ student . canterbury . ac . nz)
 ..://\/ http://cantua.canterbury.ac.nz/~mpt26/ (Site for sore eyes)
..:_/\   ASCII ART FAQ: http://cantua.canterbury.ac.nz/~mpt26/art/ascii/
  ..:/   Linux. Because life is too short to reboot.

Original message headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit
X-Google-Thread: f996b,de3737aab10fae64
X-Google-Attributes: gidf996b,public
From: Matthew Thomas <mpt...@spamfree.land>
Subject: Re: About rendering ascii code in a .txt medium
Date: 1998/09/14
Message-ID: <35F...@spamfree.land>
X-Deja-AN: 390857922
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
References: <35F...@sympatico.ca>
X-Accept-Language: en
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Organization: University of Canterbury (opinions expressed are my own)
Mime-Version: 1.0
Newsgroups: alt.ascii-art
About this message. This message was posted publicly to the newsgroup alt.ascii-art in 1998 and is mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked. The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can. Are you the author? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.

Report this message

Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.

Help classify this post