Settings

The page will reload to apply your changes.
Theme

ASCII Art Font

ASCII Art Menu

Original Usenet message from alt.ascii-art, 22 May 1998.
Re: Technology evolution and ascii pics

Re: Technology evolution and ascii pics

Matthew Thomas wrote:
<snip>
Thanks for the report card, although my psychopathologically enlarged ego
thinks that I deserve an A+  ;-))

> Whether we need to buy them is another matter. :-)
I was just describing how these "features" are making their way into
bloatware, I am not really making a marketing statement. 

> I agree with that in general -- people will be more impressed by the
> appearance of bold, italic, font color *etc* buttons in their message
> composition windows, than they will be by being told the simple fact
> that these `features' actually waste time by causing the sender to
> concentrate on form rather than content. Consider how much longer
> e-mails will take to write when you've got the tempation of changing the
> font and layout all over the place ... As an aside, the same applies to
> word processors themselves: windows festooned with toolbars, animated
> help, and all that guff only distract people ... but I'm getting
> sidetracked; that's a matter for news:comp.human-factors. The point is,
> the problem is worse in e-mail, because so many of us need to get
> e-mails written and sent quickly.

Thanks for generally agreeing, but I think you missed the point here, the
topic is ascii pics, not emails.

> *I think Pete meant `time-saving' here. But this example in particular,
> I do not understand. Is a `hasty user' *likely* to accidentally leave
> spaces at the beginning of a line? I don't think so. I would understand
> it if the program removed *all* duplicate spaces (including those at
> the beginning of a line), on the grounds of being more
> word-processor-ish; why word processors ever let you type two
> consecutive spaces is a mystery to me. But just to remove a couple from
> the beginning of a line seems bizarre.

Oops! Yes, it should be _time-saving_. 

Well, I am not going to agree or disagree whether this specific "feature"
makes things better of worse for the user. That is not the point. The point is
that these "features" _are_ being introduced, for better or for worse for the
general user. And as far ascii pics is concerned, that is never for the better
and always for the worse. (The best for ascii pics is _zero_ "features")

> In that regard I think we ASCII artists are starting to feel like
> stonemasons, or cobblers, or whatever -- in this era, except on special
> occasions, our craft is becoming obsolete. (Aargh! Heresy! Burn Matthew
> at the stake! ...) As time goes on, all the reasons for ASCII art will
> disappear -- referring to the FAQ here: (1) the universal text format
> will be HTML; (2) the difference in file size between ASCII art and
> pictures will be irrelevant, as sound and video files make even the
> largest GIF trivial in size; and (3) we will be able to copy pictures
> of any sort from one file to another just by dragging the mouse (or
> whatever); so we will only be left with (4) -- `it's fun to do'.

I think that you tie ascii art way too much to media and tecniques,
unnecessarily so. Of course, ascii art uses media and techniques as any other
art form does, but at the same time and just like any other art form, ascii
art is by itself and of itself, _not_ defined by medium and techniques. As
media and techniques are evolving, ascii art will use those evolved media and
techniques, as long as ascii art does that, it will _never_ become obsolete.

> I'm sorry, but this simply isn't true. HTML is not a WYSIWIS
> (what-you-see-is-what-I-see) medium, and never will be, due to the
> variety of software programs, OSs, and machines used to view it, and
> the variety of users who use those software programs, OSs, and
> machines. Despite <PRE>, <FONT> and all the rest of it, there is no
> getting away from the fact that HTML was designed as a *semantic*
> language, and the way particular HTML tags are rendered (or ignored)
> depends on all these things. (A few examples: the Nokia Communicator,
> the lynx and Opera Web browsers, and style sheets.)
> 
> ASCII, on the other hand, very nearly is a WYSIWIS medium. The `very
> nearly' is due to the use of serif and sans-serif fonts and fonts of
> different aspect ratios, but these differences are trivial in most
> cases.

ascii is WYSIWIS only if both maker and viewer use simple text editors. But my
whole point is, that this assumption is (slowly) becoming invalid with email
and newsgroup software (slowly) becoming "feature" laden bloatware. The point
will be reached where html will have the better chances for WYSIWIS, because
it has the ascii information _plus_ diplay instructions (in the form of html
tags.) 

> The only HTML tags required for ASCII art are <PRE> and </PRE>;
> Netscape Composer has a `Formatted' choice in its style menu which
> inserts these (although that's hardly obvious, is it?)

That's taking a myopic view. If ascii art as an art form by itself and of
itself (see above) makes use of the html medium and techniques, then broader
possibilities open up, such as no limits on pagewidth, half spaces, font
faces, colour, etc. See also a parallel article of mine in this thread.

> Yes :-( . I mentioned this when writing the FAQ last year.
> Overeagerness on Netscape's part, I think, as well as a reckless
> disregard for bandwidth.

I fear that Netscape may not care much about your FAQ  :-))

> I think there is an alternative long-term strategy, and that is to
> petition Mozilla.org, and other e-mail program producers, to provide
> easier selection of whether a message is to be sent as plain text or in
> HTML -- for example, some sort of drop-down menu in the composition
> window. This wouldn't be just for us a.a-aers; many, many people have
> ASCII art of some description in their sig files alone, and of course
> some people realize the stupidity (described above) of including fancy
> formatting in messages which are going to be read and deleted within
> minutes.

I fear that Netscape may not care much about your ascii pics  :-))

But kidding aside, ascii pics is a rather small application, and as any other
small applications, it has to live with mainstream applications (Battling
mainstream applications is useless, that's were the money is.)

Living with mainstream applications is the very reason why I pointed out
workarounds such as cautiously using only columns #3 to #73 for ascii pics.
Well, ascii pics living in an increasingly hostile world of mainstream
applications is the very reason why I started this discussion thread ...

=========================================================
[]      ,,                                             []
[]     ( ">      Visit the Gallery of the 'steins!     []
[]    ,(> )>    http://www3.sympatico.ca/petecasso/    []
[]   (  ^^     Devilstein, who sired all the 'steins   []
[]                                                     []
=========================================================

Original message headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit
X-Google-Thread: f996b,cc07b6bb8d657c99
X-Google-Attributes: gidf996b,public
From: Pete Casso <pet...@sympatico.ca>
Subject: Re: Technology evolution and ascii pics
Date: 1998/05/22
Message-ID: <356...@sympatico.ca>
X-Deja-AN: 355476177
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
References: <356...@sympatico.ca> <356...@spamfree.land>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Organization: Frogstein and Birdstein Productions
MIME-Version: 1.0
NNTP-Posting-Date: Fri, 22 May 1998 03:12:42 EDT
Newsgroups: alt.ascii-art
About this message. This message was posted publicly to the newsgroup alt.ascii-art in 1998 and is mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked. The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can. Are you the author? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.

Report this message

Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.

Help classify this post