Settings

The page will reload to apply your changes.
Theme

ASCII Art Font

ASCII Art Menu

Original Usenet message from alt.ascii-art, 1 Jun 1999.
Re: Rude folks, indeed.....

Re: Rude folks, indeed.....

Dear Patches,

    Thank you for your repost. It was honest and informative. I am pleased to hear that
you are participating in that "Respect Ascii Artists" campaign, and that your helpers
ask newcomers to the hobby of colorizing ascii to please credit the originators of the
text-pictures they copy and colorize for IRC.

    It is perfectly understandable that you haven't always had the same awareness about
crediting the "artists" of askey in the past, and that you have files available on your
web site which reflect this. Many of these folks who make ascii did not have any information
on their web pages about their wishes concerning the use of their pictures, until recently.
Some still may not. Although most have always been irritated by the plagiary of their askii,
the colorization and use of it on IRC hasn't attracted a lot of attention, here.

    Plagiary of small things is still plagiary, and to those who would not wish to be
plagiarized, it is of little concern whether it is petty or grandiose. It is nice
that you are doing what you can to take note of it, when you see it on IRC.

    I looked at your web page, and several other mirc color-sites recently. Many of them
are quite large, and contain a multitude of colorized files for use on IRC. One thing that
they all share in common, is that all of these sites contain text-pictures that were made
by people on this newsgroup. Credit to the authors of those pictures was done in various
ways by the people who had colored them, although there were many that gave no credit at
all. I saw none where someone was deliberately claiming authorship of ascii pictures that
they had not done, but did see ones where it was practically done so by inference. Of the
files I looked at on these sites, the uncredited ones seemed to be in the majority, although
I will add that I can't claim to have seen enough of them to state that as prevalent. Adding
"color by whoever" to a colorized ascii picture, without including the artist's initials, is
intentionally misleading, however. The credited files, and totally non-credited files were
much more wholesome to see.

    Since the small number of us who post regularly to alt.ascii-art and/or maintain websites
of ascii seem to be a resource for IRC-color enthusiasts, I found one thing about these "Rainbow"
and "Color" websites offering colorized text-art in mass quantities disappointing. That was the
almost complete lack of mention given to the people who really make the ascii that is so loved
for colorization on IRC. Even on your own web site, what I saw was links to this newsgroup, and
the "Ultimate Ascii Links" web page, which were listed as "Places To Get Ascii". Not "Places To
See Ascii By The People Who Make It", or "Great Ascii Pages", or even "Ascii Websites". Just "places
to get it". There were a couple of other pages that listed such links also, and in a similar
way. I'm sure everyone would like to think that IRC people who look at these websites aren't
just browsing in to "get ascii".

 ... It kind of makes B'ger and Joan and Flump and others look a little bit like trollops, and
Andreas and Erik "The Dick" Veland look like pimps.

    Except for one page, there was no mention about the folks who make ascii. That page were jus'
suckin' up to Joan, anyways. I figger she's glad to knoe that sumboddy does, in case she doan
alreddy.

    It might be nice to see a little more attention paid to the wording of some of those links
to ascii sites (some pages have none at all, of course). Or a kind word or two on these
IRC-color sites about the people who produce original ascii-art; at least the ones they like
to color so much (which depends on the color site, of course). There is plenty to read on them
about these mirc-color-artists who colored these pictures.

    Credit should go to where credit is due, of course.

    I will be as frank as you have tried to be. Myself, I have a little trouble calling ascii "art".
I don't even call my own real cartoons art. I suppose they both are, but I was raised around people
who made serious art; the kind that hangs in places like the Smithsonian Institute. Text-art is a
type of pop-art, and I like making it, but I joke about it being "art". Most people do consider it
art, however, and although I may jibe the other regulars here about that, art is in the eye of the
beholder. The consensus is against me about ascii being art, although none would argue (I think)
about it comparing to some other, more serious forms. Regardless, I have real trouble in considering
mirc-colorizations as art, at all.

    I have seen some of those colorized files that actually make a picture of something when played
on IRC. There are many of these, although they are in the minority. Although different from asskey,
they really do make a picture, and so qualify as "art". Others are likewise text-art, and some are
extended character text-art. The majority of these color-texts are borders and curlicues, however...
and colorized ascii, the finest of which is taken from folks here, of course. Much of the ascii has
had non-standard characters added to enhance it on IRC, and/or other alterations which are usually
intended to make some kind of "unique" modification, without really "changing" the text-picture.
Colorizing ascii and fancy bordering just isn't art, however. It's just coloring. Some of it is
quite striking, but it doesn't qualify as art, and can't be compared to making ascii, or making an
actual picture by using colorization.

    The glorification, zealousness, and jealous arguments that surrounds "mirc-art" strikes me as
faintly ridiculous. I have been getting a good bit of email from some IRC-color enthusiasts, and
they all discuss this. I understand there are arguments about who colorized what ascii. Gee... I'm
sure Krogg would be pleased to hear there are ladies out there, seething and ready to kill because
someone else colored their colorized ascii file a different color. Probably one that somebody else
had already colored, already. Fascinating...

    On the other hand, coloring ascii and making colored pictures and borders is your hobby, so dealing
with those issues is best left to those involved. I won't pretend to understand it.

    For instance, I am told that portions of your repost are aimed at Ole, aka Dane, who I am glad
has a real name. I don't think that conflicts over color websites and scripts and such are of much
value here, although they are interesting.

    I wish you much luck in making known whoever the man was that you mentioned was displaying pirated
acii-art. I think the best path for exposing a plagiarist in action on IRC, is that taken by
the "fans", or "users" of ascii art, who recognize he or she as such. We on AAA infrequently have to point
out that someone new to this newsgroup is posting a picture that was done by previously by someone else,
and is trying to claim it as their own. Those kind of folks usually don't return and make more posts,
after being exposed. The problem is different on IRC, because you are dealing with "chat", which is gone
as soon as you close the program. Here, there are many more readers, and the media has some permanent
aspects to it, in that posts are archived. The participants of a chat are limited at any instant to the
channel or channels that they are on where something is happening, and when they notice a plagiarist,
exposing such a person is effective primarily in one channel, at that given time. That person can always
come back with a different nickname another time, or simply move to a different channel and/or network.
Unless they become a real terror with their activities, there is little chance that anyone will complain
to the administrator of the network. Posting some kind of alert on your web page about an ascii pirate
might be an effective means of letting others know about that person's behavior.


    As to the production of mass numbers of color files, I guess that's an IRC issue which doesn't
really have a comparison here. More asskey art would just be more ascie art, and the more the better.
I'm certain the IRC-color enthusiast feels the same way about there being more askii art to pick
and choose from. We'd just as soon see people make all they can, and there's not really any competition
as to how many everyone can make. Quality isn't that big an issue, especially considering there aren't
many people making it all the time. I'm not sure it would be, even if there were. A text-picture is a
text-picture, and almost all of them have merit.

    There are many places on-line to get free things like backgrounds, wallpaper, ect.. Lots of that,
and other items, come without credits or restrictions on their usage. Many of the graphic artists who
produced some of those items did receive recognition - often in the form of a paycheck. No one pays
an ascii-artist for making a text-picture. They do it for fun, and would appreciate being known for
making the askei that they did make, instead of having someone steal it. There are plenty of graphic
artists who also do pictures, ect., for pure joy. I have not seen many people attempting to garnish
credit by plagiary of a background image; not yet, anyway. If it's a problem for the graphic artists
who do those things, then they should address it themselves. I haven't witnessed much of that kind
of thing, and am not able to comment with celerity upon it.

    Fortunately, there are not many ascii art sites that don't give credit to the authors who made
the pictures. There are pictures whose author is unknown, but there a site that doesn't credit
the artist is a rare thing, unless you are talking about IRC-color sites. There may be many of those,
but not ascii sites that don't credit the authors. There have been some ascii sites that were posted
by plagiarists, and those have upset ascii artists, on occasion. I believe most of those sites no
longer exist, and I don't think there were many, or that they were well-known in the first place.
Most ascii artists take a different view about some 10-year old kid who posts a homepage with an
ascii that is without credits or that they have credited to themselves, than to an ascii page that
contains many pictures that are stolen or deliberately miscredited. If you know of pages such as
these, whether they are real ascii sites or IRC-color sites, I think we can speak for everybody
in that we would like to know where they are.

    Which brings me to another point you made in your repost. Who is this [quote]"mass-producer of
color art that doesn't often give credit, because she believes that once she alters original ascii
art, it becomes hers"[endquote]? Sure sounds like "maryemd" to me. If it's maryemd or not, I think
folks here on AAA would like to know about her. If you can help with some kind of support to your
claim, which I do not doubt is quite true, it would be most kind of you.

    Ascii art is free. It's made and posted here on aaa, and on webpages which are mostly
associated with this newsgroup. The "artists" who make these pictures are all happy to share them
with whoever enjoys the pictures they make, author, type, draw, or whatever you want to call it.
They receive little encouragement, less recognition, and no pay for their efforts which many
appreciate with only a passing muse of how clever it is. Perhaps that is how it should be, because
a text-picture is usually as fleeting as yesterday's newspaper... or cartoon (I guess if you combine
the two, you are really fucked). The people who make this humble artwork crave nothing of anyone,
except that they are not stolen from them.


    I reckon I have responded to most of your repost, Patches. Since you are both knowledgeable and
have taken an interest in this issue, perhaps you would be good enough to drop us a line, or a post
about where it's going on IRC. I myself think that more of you colored-IRC folks ere tryin' to give
credit to peeple here who make asskey, than ere not. It is nice that you are considerin' the small
ree-spects that asskee are-teests would like to git, since so much of it are used on IRC.

                                Thanks agin,
                               Jonathon R. Oglesbee
                            oglesbee@
                                    mail.fullnet.net

Original message headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit
X-Google-Thread: f996b,9582a06ad20d3f3b
X-Google-Attributes: gidf996b,public
From: "JRO" <ogl...@mail.fullnet.net-remove>
Subject: Re: Rude folks, indeed.....
Date: 1999/06/01
Message-ID: <3753e97d.0@206.103.97.91>
X-Deja-AN: 484464172
References: <374fbe76.0@206.103.97.91> <bOo43.25827$tm6...@news.rdc1.sdca.home.com>
X-MSMail-Priority: Normal
X-Priority: 3
Newsgroups: alt.ascii-art
X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V5.00.2314.1300
About this message. This message was posted publicly to the newsgroup alt.ascii-art in 1999 and is mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked. The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can. Are you the author? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.

Report this message

Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.

Help classify this post