Settings

The page will reload to apply your changes.
Theme

ASCII Art Font

ASCII Art Menu

Original Usenet thread from alt.ascii-art, started 11 Sep 1994.
 _   _                     _        _             _     _           
| | | |___  ___ _ __   ___| |_     / \   _ __ ___| |__ (_)_   _____ 
| | | / __|/ _ \ '_ \ / _ \ __|   / _ \ | '__/ __| '_ \| \ \ / / _ \
| |_| \__ \  __/ | | |  __/ |_   / ___ \| | | (__| | | | |\ V /  __/
 \___/|___/\___|_| |_|\___|\__| /_/   \_\_|  \___|_| |_|_| \_/ \___|
Should IDs be put at the end? (question)

Should IDs be put at the end? (question)

alt.ascii-art · 4 messages · 11 Sep 1994 - 12 Sep 1994
Bob Allison <bob...@wwa.com> ASCII art 11 Sep 1994 14:54 · permalink · report

   I would rather see a post with an ID than without.  It helps to know 
if it's a request, pic, talk, etc.  But they are in your face at the 
beginning of the line.

   How about if we put them at the end (except on long subject linss)?  
Maybe in (), or not.  It would be there, but be out of the way.  This 
makes sense if most readers don't always need to look at it.  What do you 
think?

--
               .:   ::   ::::::::
            .:::::::::: ::  ::::     .:     .::::::::::::::.
              :::::::   :   ::      ::::::::::::::::::::  :
             :::::::::::        : ::::::::::::::::::::::
    ======  ======::======  ======::======::======::======: ======  ==  ==  ==
   ==      ==::::::==::==  ==  ==  ==::::::==::: ::== :==::==::==: ==  ==  ==
  ======  == :  ::======  ======  ====::::==:::: :======::==::==  ==  ==  ==
     ==  ==      ==: ==  == ==   ==    ::==::::  == ==:: == :==  ==  ==  ==
======  ======  ==  ==::==  ==  ====== :======: ==  ==  ======  ==========
                  .::::::.             :::::: :                :.
                   :::::::             ::::: :            .:: :
                    ::::                ::             .::::::.
                     ::                                ::  :::  :
                     ;                                         ;

Bob Allison (bob...@wwa.com) wrote:

:    I would rather see a post with an ID than without.  It helps to know
: if it's a request, pic, talk, etc.  But they are in your face at the
: beginning of the line.

:    How about if we put them at the end (except on long subject linss)?

Well, Bob, how long is long?  For the title of this original message,
my newsreader clipped the '(question)' to '(questi'.  I personally think
that having the IDs, period, is good idea, but I think having them at the
beginning is more natural than the end.  Since most of us (or perhaps I
should say all of us who read Western languages), psychologically, as well
as, logically, expect to find classifiers or anything else on which we
base a decision to be located at the beginning, that is, on the left.

I might also add that I think having them in all caps is preferable to
mixed case for the reason I find them easier to scan that way, that is,
they seem to stand out more from the rest of the text.

Just my thoughts.

--
 "..."    <-- either an ellipsis OR a toothy Cheshire gila monster's smile(y)

Michael J Ciha <mci...@ins.infonet.net> ASCII art 12 Sep 1994 21:18 · permalink · report
In article <34v5mu$d4...@gagme.wwa.com>, bob...@wwa.com (Bob Allison) writes:
>   I would rather see a post with an ID than without.  It helps to know
>if it's a request, pic, talk, etc.  But they are in your face at the
>beginning of the line.
>
>   How about if we put them at the end (except on long subject linss)?
>Maybe in (), or not.  It would be there, but be out of the way.  This
>makes sense if most readers don't always need to look at it.  What do you
>think?

Well, I got as far as "(q" as for seeing if this was a "Question".

I like it at the beginning...


--
------------------------------------------------------------------------
=)
Michael J Ciha                   Teach your kids the value of a dollar.
mci...@ins.infonet.net             Give them a dime.
                                   - Sid Ascher

In article <34v5mu$d4...@gagme.wwa.com> Bob Allison, bob...@wwa.com writes:
>    I would rather see a post with an ID than without.  It helps to know 
> if it's a request, pic, talk, etc.  But they are in your face at the 
> beginning of the line.
> 

Well Bob, Just to add my $.02.  I like the fact that the articles are now
sorted on my machine into REQUESTS, QUESTIONS, TALK, LINE, GIF, and the
misc. non-identified stuff. and then sub-sorted (for the most part) by
the rest of the subject.    You see I can decide, "oh gee I don't have a
lot of time I'll just read the line art today" and it's all right there
grouped together.... I don't have to scan the whole group for what I want
it's all right there (kinnda like how threading works on a threaded news
reader). In fact, I like it so much that it becomes annoying when people
do not use the identifiers.

For instance today I found one article identified as line:, and many
identified as request:  and I knew exactly what to expect... the other 50
posts I had to thumb through to figure out what they contained... (most
of them wasting my time although I really like the dragon posts... would
have been nice to know they were line though.)

To summarize:  While yes the ID may be in you face, with a threaded news
reader that sorts by subject, reading news is simplified.  If ID,s were
put at the ends of lines the sorting would not "categorize" articles and
it would be like reading unthreaded/unsorted news (and personally I don't
want to go back to Readnews.

About this thread. These messages were posted publicly to the newsgroup alt.ascii-art in 1994 and are mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked. The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can. Are you one of the authors? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.

Report this message

Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.

Help classify this post