Original Usenet thread from alt.ascii-art, started 23 May 1994.
VOTING: rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED)
alt.ascii-art
· 8 messages · 23 May 1994 - 24 May 1994
[ This posting is not in the usual format due to a hardware failure destroying the earlier postings so that a normal reply cannot be made ] In reply to the posting by Dwayne Jarvis, ( actually Rowan Crawford, ROW ) who wrote: First let me say that I am pleased you have entered the public debate and regret that you did not do so much earlier when the RFD ( Request for Discussion ) was taking place and before this late stage in the voting proceedings. THE BIG APPEAL OF ALT.ASCII-ART: ROW> What is the big appeal of a.a-a? - Freedom for all comers. - Lots of pictures. - Lots of requests :-) - Great enjoyment for many users ( regrettably not all ). - The potential to become one of the top ten groups. An estimated 86,000 readers and a site propagation level of 44% in just a few months of the group's formation is remarkable for any group - _and_ a group not regarded as a "proper" newsgroup according to the proponents of rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED ). The results to date speak for themselves. REQUESTS, REQUESTS, REQUESTS: Battle cry of the moderationists. CD> Do you seriously believe that this an acceptable response to CD> _any_ reader's request for one picture ? Not only is it CD> unfriendly, it is inappropriate, frustrating and bordering on the CD> ridiculous. > It's actually a very standardized way to deal with such things as FAQs. > Many groups do this because it's efficiant. Many groups ? Name them. Standardized ? Which standard is that then ? > Wo wo wo. etc.... Sounds like you're calling in the horses. We say " Git in behind ! " this side of the Tasman. :-) > requests. Am I clear on what I mean there? Sure. You're meaning is clear enough. It is your understanding of the true nature of requests that is flawed. Frankly, I despair of ever being able to get this message across to the anti-request brigade. Here we go for the umpteenth time: To the requester each and every request is _new_ and quite normal. Popular subjects are bound to be requested frequently but by _ENTIRELY DIFFERENT PEOPLE_ who simply have not seen all the other requests. Newcomers are arriving in the group continuously and at a great rate. > Requests were never what a.a-a were about originally. There were very few people reading the group originally. > It's only lately that they have - quite literally - taken over the > group. I consider that nonsense - I've been reading this group since about late September 1993 - as soon as I heard about it - and I simply do not agree with you - so there ! :-) :-) > They dont fit into the reason why a.a-a was created in the first > place, although of course they have some relevance. Well you had better post the alt.ascii-art Charter because I am sure most of us haven't seen it - so how can we assess the validity of your statements ? Perhaps it would help if the Charter appeared continuously in this newsgroup for all to see. > There's no doubting that requests have killed original art here > (anyone dissagree?). Yes, I disagree. If those people who can produce original art are sulking and unwilling to contribute to alt.ascii-art because of requests then it is they themselves who are killing the "original art" postings. C'mon Row, that's kindergarten stuff - " It's my ball and if you don't play to my rules I'm taking my ball away. " This newsgroup is alt.ascii-art not alt.ascii-original-art or alt.ascii-prima donnas. > I used to collect the stuff from here, and it's got to the point > now where I hardly save anything. I have to agree that that is rather sad to hear. At the same time it also is not very charitable reflection on all the stuff that has been and continues to be posted here. It is not by any means rubbish and many others have praised the content of alt.ascii-art. If you have not been earning admiration and accolades it may be that you have not posted much for some time, whether by design or circumstance I cannot know. > I personally would be *very* happy to start afresh on a new group > where requests did not eat at 90% of the postings. That is obvious but not very helpful to the rest of us. Come to think of it I have never seen you answer a request. Why do you leave it all to other folks ? > Your quite free to stick around a.a-a and have it as a request for > ascii pictures. That's big of you to grant me that freedom. OTHER MATTERS: > But perhaps it's a little bit too much trying to actively stop > r.a.a simply because you like a.a-a as it is. Sure, vote a NO if > thats what you wish, but many of your negative comments here are > badly uninformed. And what about all your negative comments about this newsgroup alt.ascii-art ? Are they justified and superbly informed ? Not in my opinion. Is it also a concession to be allowed a NO vote ? - the number of times I have been asked to vote yes or not vote NO is astounding - and I have seen the same thing happen to other people. It is a wonder that a NO vote is even being permitted on this issue. > Just think, if r.a.a *did* pass, then you could have the best of > both worlds - an unmoderated group for endless requests and > reports, and a moderated group devoted to ascii art itself. I think that sort of attitude is simply unworthy of you and really quite insulting to other folks who may not equal your artistic talent. It is very sad that that is how you see things, but that's the way of it I guess. > Just a quick word about the moderation. It would be practically > invisable to the regular users, and would *only* filter things > which the majority of subscribers dont want to see. You don't really believe all that do you ? > Nothing fairer than that. As a "Fair Dinkum Aussie" you have a strange concept of fairness. > PS. No flame intended. Just trying to clear up some things. No flame taken. You have every right to put express your views - make the most of it in this free unmoderated newsgroup :-) :-) Bye,
There are a couple of things I have to say about all this. 1) Requests are part of the life blood of alt.ascii-art! How often has someone posted a request which has caused a new pic to be created, an old pic to be altered or unseen pics to be released? Sure Bob could reply to requests posted on the net but that wouldn't get the same variety of results. Personally I like to see requests and more particularily their followups being posted to the group. 2) Sure some pictures get posted often enough to make people well and truly sick of them. That's because they are spectacular art. We don't _HAVE_ to look at them each time they show up! 3) What good does sending out a FAQ do? If it's to point you towards ftp sites, not everyone has ftp priviledges. If it's to tell you how to draw them yourself, not everyone has the talent! ++++++ In fact I voted YES but now I'm not so sure. Does anyone know the procedure for changing your vote? ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ David Mc Auley Trinity College Dublin mca...@unix1.tcd.ie Disclaimer -- My college cannot be responsible for my opinions. Nor can I for that matter!!! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>ROW> What is the big appeal of a.a-a? >- Freedom for all comers. >- Lots of pictures. >- Lots of requests :-) >- Great enjoyment for many users ( regrettably not all ). >- The potential to become one of the top ten groups. Not what I meant. Every time someone says "replace a.a-a with r.a.a (m)" you jump in and say that a.a-a is not being replaced. If r.a.a (mod) does pass, then I would surely consider it a move. The fact that a.a-a would not be deleted means it could be put to other use. Maybe a good opportunity? >REQUESTS, REQUESTS, REQUESTS: Battle cry of the moderationists. And why not? If the voter doesn't enjoy reading requests, then why not take the opportunity to vote for a moderated group? I did ;). [see my other post somewhere for why I am against requests to an extent] >> It's actually a very standardized way to deal with such things as FAQs. >> Many groups do this because it's efficiant. >Many groups ? Name them. Geez, pop onto misc.answers (or that FAQ ftp site which I can't think of at the moment). I can only imagine that "most" (purely imaginative use of the word) groups try their best to cut down on repeat *anythings* via a FAQ. No? >Standardized ? Which standard is that then ? Standard: usual, regular (thesaurus alternatives) If still confused, consult previous responce. >To the requester each and every request is _new_ and quite normal. >Popular subjects are bound to be requested frequently but by >_ENTIRELY DIFFERENT PEOPLE_ who simply have not seen all the other >Newcomers are arriving in the group continuously and at a great rate. Don't forget this is a *personal* vote. In other words, people vote for what -they- would like to happen, not for what someone else might like. I'm quite aware of why requests are popular, and why the same ones apear so often. I never implied otherwise. >I consider that nonsense - I've been reading this group since about >late September 1993 - as soon as I heard about it - and I simply do >not agree with you - so there ! :-) :-) Mistake in that paragraph: you acknowledge that we have different *opinions* and yet you call my statement "nonsense". How can my own personal opion be nonsense? (I hope I dont need to make a .sig with a disclaimer in it ;) >Well you had better post the alt.ascii-art Charter because I am sure I was not aware that an alt. group required a Charter? However, I feel quite comfident in stating that a.a-a was not created with requests in mind. Not too much of an assumption I assume. >" It's my ball and if you >don't play to my rules I'm taking my ball away. " Well, thats fair enough. But how your relating that to the CFV of r.a.a (mod) I'm not entirely sure ;). >also is not very charitable reflection on all the stuff that has >been and continues to be posted here. It is not by any means rubbish >and many others have praised the content of alt.ascii-art. I dont like it when people twist my words. >think of it I have never seen you answer a request. Why do you leave >it all to other folks ? Because my ascii collection consists of maybe two dozen pics, and it would take me quite a bit of work to upload them here (seriously: copy to ram - gzip it - set system to binary - upload picture - gunzip it - find request post again - inport pic into reply = why would I go through that when there are others who can grab something from their FTP collection in less than 30 seconds? (assuming they know the file names)). >> Your quite free to stick around a.a-a and have it as a request for >> ascii pictures. >That's big of you to grant me that freedom. There you go twisting my words again. You're not a politician by any chance? ;) >And what about all your negative comments about this newsgroup >alt.ascii-art ? Are they justified and superbly informed ? AGAIN, my opinion (did I miss reading something that said personal opinions are not allowed? ;). >I think that sort of attitude is simply unworthy of you and really >quite insulting to other folks who may not equal your artistic >talent. It is very sad that that is how you see things, but that's >the way of it I guess. Argh! What a cheap way to create an insulting paragraph! >As a "Fair Dinkum Aussie" you have a strange concept of fairness. And there's another one. --- That reply took about 45 minutes to write. I hope I don't have to "disclaim" everything I write once again ;). Row.
>1) Requests are part of the life blood of alt.ascii-art! How often >has someone posted a request which has caused a new pic to be created, >an old pic to be altered or unseen pics to be released? Sure Bob could >reply to requests posted on the net but that wouldn't get the same >variety of results. Personally I like to see requests and more >particularily their followups being posted to the group. This whole request issue seems to have become quite an important point to a lot of people. Remember that a.a-a will still be here, will still be unmoderated, and will still be read by a lot of people. Secondly, although I cant quote the CFV text since I haven't got it handy, I'm pretty sure that requests were going to be posted?! It was just the frequently requested pics which the moderator might choose to send straight to the postee. For example, the globe.vt posting - when it appeared, that was quite literally requested HEAPS of times inside a couple of weeks (and it was a big file). There would be no harm in the moderator sending either the file or an FTP site once the number of requests reaches a certain point. >2) Sure some pictures get posted often enough to make people well >and truly sick of them. That's because they are spectacular art. We >don't _HAVE_ to look at them each time they show up! It's not necessarily a case of "spectacular art" unfortunately (with a few noted exceptions such as Meriday (in the morning)). It's more likely to be a case of a) a popular character, or b) people hear/see mention of something which they missed, or didn't bother saving. >3) What good does sending out a FAQ do? If it's to point you >towards ftp sites, not everyone has ftp priviledges. The FAQ would be very informative to any new subscribers. The FTP sites with ascii art are a BRILLIANT supply of all types of pics, so anyone with a request would probably die to find such stores. If the person doesn't have FTP access, then they could just point it out to the moderator and the post would possibly go through. But there was talk of automating the moderation process a bit, so people could actually get files via email. Any news on that Bob? >++++++ In fact I voted YES but now I'm not so sure. Does anyone know >the procedure for changing your vote? Simply vote again except with the NO in place of the YES. You can change your mind as often as you like up until the dealine (whenever that is). I'm not fussed whether people vote YES or NO, just as long as they do what they think is best. Row.
In article <dljar1.769696301@giaeb>
dlj...@giaeb.cc.monash.edu.au "Dwayne Jarvis" writes:
> >> Your quite free to stick around a.a-a and have it as a request for
> >> ascii pictures.
>
> >That's big of you to grant me that freedom.
>
> There you go twisting my words again. You're not a politician by any chance? ;)
>
> >And what about all your negative comments about this newsgroup
> >alt.ascii-art ? Are they justified and superbly informed ?
>
> AGAIN, my opinion (did I miss reading something that said personal opinions
> are not allowed? ;).
>
> >I think that sort of attitude is simply unworthy of you and really
> >quite insulting to other folks who may not equal your artistic
> >talent. It is very sad that that is how you see things, but that's
> >the way of it I guess.
>
> Argh! What a cheap way to create an insulting paragraph!
>
> >As a "Fair Dinkum Aussie" you have a strange concept of fairness.
>
> And there's another one.
>
> ---
> That reply took about 45 minutes to write. I hope I don't have to
> "disclaim" everything I write once again ;).
>
> Row.
>
The tendency to take the high moral ground and then use that position to
deliberately distort his opponents views is absolutely typical of Colin's
rhetoric. I also have had recent occasion to point this out to him. This
rather childish and crude method of justifying his own paranoiac ideas
gives little substance to anything he has to say. My advice would be to
ignore him and focus your attention on more informed opinion.
Paul.
>From: Col...@equinox.gen.nz (Colin Douthwaite) >First let me say that I am pleased you have entered the public >debate and regret that you did not do so much earlier when the RFD >( Request for Discussion ) was taking place and before this late >stage in the voting proceedings. Some of us would rather be drawing than debating... >THE BIG APPEAL OF ALT.ASCII-ART: >- Freedom for all comers. Strange, I thought all groups had that characteristic. >- Lots of pictures. True, many of which are repeats though. >- Lots of requests :-) Yes, that could be a viewed as a drawback though, not an appeal! >- Great enjoyment for many users ( regrettably not all ). So be it. There is no way to please everybody anyway. >- The potential to become one of the top ten groups. If I understand the group hierarchies correctly, the propagation of alt groups is the limiting factor of that "potential". That is why a rec group is being considered as the next step in the propagation of ASCII art. >Sure. You're meaning is clear enough. It is your understanding of the >true nature of requests that is flawed. How easy it is to blame the other side. >Frankly, I despair of ever being able to get this message across to >the anti-request brigade. Here we go for the umpteenth time: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ That is a very negative opinion. You seem to dismiss entirely the fact that several people that are not in your camp, care just as much about ASCII art as you do (and some maybe even more so). You seem to have shifted gears from "let's discuss the pros and cons of rec.arts.ascii" to "let's attack those that don't think like me by using subtle associations". I just hope that people will be smart enough to see through your ploys. >To the requester each and every request is _new_ and quite normal. I agree. No one has ever argued against that fact though. >Popular subjects are bound to be requested frequently but by >_ENTIRELY DIFFERENT PEOPLE_ who simply have not seen all the other >requests. I agree. Again, no one ever said that "THE SAME PEOPLE KEEP REQUESTING THE SAME PICTURES!" I discovered the validity of your above two statements in my first two weeks of browsing through a.a-a in early December last year. You are bringing nothing new to the table. The question still remains: why is it good for the group to have about 100 duplicated requests a month (just a guess) for particular pictures and 100 replies to those requests when ALL THE WORLD sees both every time? There has to be a better way to deal with satisfying the needs of the requesters while at the same time minimizing the waste. Perhaps rec.arts.ascii (as proposed) is not the best solution, but it is at least trying to address the problem. >Newcomers are arriving in the group continuously and at a great rate. That is probably due to the reputation of the art displayed here, not the requests! >> It's only lately that they have - quite literally - taken over the >> group. > >I consider that nonsense - I've been reading this group since about >late September 1993 - as soon as I heard about it - and I simply do >not agree with you - so there ! :-) :-) The man is allowed an opinion and so are you. That doesn't mean you're right and he's wrong or that he's right and you're wrong. Somehow I'm under the impression that you would have disagreed no matter what the comment had been. :-) >If those people who can produce original art are sulking and >unwilling to contribute to alt.ascii-art because of requests then it >is they themselves who are killing the "original art" postings. Wait a second. Another misrepresentation: no one ever said "REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF REQUESTS IN THIS GROUP OR I WILL STOP POSTING HERE". As far as I understand, rec.arts.ascii was proposed as a means to increase the access to ASCII art and at the same time to help conserve bandwidth and save people time and money by managing waste. If rec.arts.ascii fails, I will continue to post to alt.ascii-art unless of course KING DOUTHWAITE manages to convince people that I was a traitor and therefore that I should not be allowed to post here any more. :-) >C'mon Row, that's kindergarten stuff - " It's my ball and if you >don't play to my rules I'm taking my ball away. " > >This newsgroup is alt.ascii-art not alt.ascii-original-art or >alt.ascii-prima donnas. These personal attacks serve no purpose other than to try to inflame the perceived enemies. >> I used to collect the stuff from here, and it's got to the point >> now where I hardly save anything. > >I have to agree that that is rather sad to hear. At the same time it >also is not very charitable reflection on all the stuff that has >been and continues to be posted here. It is not by any means rubbish >and many others have praised the content of alt.ascii-art. I must agree with Row on this one. I use to be able to save one post out of every five back in January. Now a days I save about 5 posts per 100. Please note that Row did not say "all pictures posted here are crap" but rather "there is far less pictures than there use to be". Who wants to collect requests anyway? There has indeed been several praises of a.a-a, but I do not recall having seen even one that said "oh, I love all the requests I see in here." >If you have not been earning admiration and accolades it may be that >you have not posted much for some time, whether by design or >circumstance I cannot know. Here we go again: another attempt at trying to inflame Row. You seem to be inventing stuff Colin: where did Row say something like "I hate this group now, because no one seems to care whenever I post a picture?" >> Your quite free to stick around a.a-a and have it as a request for >> ascii pictures. > >That's big of you to grant me that freedom. I don't get it! You complain that people are attempting to reduce the amount of requests, yet when someone offers an alternative that will let you see all the requests, you bitch about it! Why not make suggestions to modify the charter for rec.arts.ascii so that its goals are met in ways that you can agree with instead of whining in public? So far, you have only muddled the issues instead of bringing forth constructive criticism. >Is it also a concession to be allowed a NO vote ? - the number of >times I have been asked to vote yes or not vote NO is astounding - >and I have seen the same thing happen to other people. It is a >wonder that a NO vote is even being permitted on this issue. What is that suppose to mean? We are an "anti-NO brigade" I suppose? Stick to the topic will you. No one is preventing you to vote the way you want or to express your opinion. Stop hurling around false accusations. >> Just think, if r.a.a *did* pass, then you could have the best of >> both worlds - an unmoderated group for endless requests and >> reports, and a moderated group devoted to ascii art itself. > >I think that sort of attitude is simply unworthy of you and really >quite insulting to other folks who may not equal your artistic >talent. It is very sad that that is how you see things, but that's >the way of it I guess. Again! You complain that requests will be cut, yet you also complain if provisions are made so that you are allowed to see them all! BTW, who ever gave you the right to represent the "other folks". Let them state their own opinion. [Other low blows deleted] >> PS. No flame intended. Just trying to clear up some things. > >No flame taken. You have every right to put express your views - >make the most of it in this free unmoderated newsgroup :-) :-) You might not have taken it as a flame, but you certainly made several comments that appear to have been intended to create more than just little sparks. It is really deplorable to see an avid ASCII lover like yourself resort to manipulative techniques to distort the words of other ASCII lovers. Sorry, but that does not earn you any points in my book. -- Normand Veilleux As a "long term" contributing artist to nve...@emr1.emr.ca alt.ascii-art, I hereby declare that ---------------------------- rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED) has my support.
OK, I made up my mind. I voted "NO" to rec.ascii arts. Two reasons: 1) I know what Alt.a-a is like, and I like it. Why take chances? 2) The only big waste of bandwidth here these days is the r.a.a debate, and the only thing that I want to see in a FAQ is the addresses of the people who keep posting to VOTING:..., so that they all can assault each other via e-mail. :-) (Myself included) Now for some art: .............. .............. .............. .............. .............. : .______. : .______. : .______. : .______. : .______. : : / \ : / \ : / \ : / \ : / \ : : | | : | | : | | : | | : | | : : | ._ ._ | : | ._ ._ | : | ._ ._ | : | ._ ._ | : | ._ ._ | : : Y (##)\##) Y : Y (##)\##) Y : Y (##)\##) Y : Y (##)\##) Y : Y (##)\##) Y : : l "'/\"' ; : l "'/\"' ; : l "'/\"' ; : l "'/\"' ; : l "'/\"' ; : : \ "' / : \ "' / : \ "' / : \ "' / : \ "' / : : |_||||_| : |_||||_| : |_||||_| : |_||||_| : |_||||_| : : \T!!!!T/ : \T!!!!T/ : \T!!!!T/ : \T!!!!T/ : \T!!!!T/ : : ^^^^^ : ^^^^^ : ^^^^^ : ^^^^^ : ^^^^^ : .............. .............. .............. .............. .............. -Ian -- ia...@venus.engr.ucdavis.edu | | UCD Mech & Aero, #02404; Davis, CA 95616 ---------------------------' `------------------------------------------ =========================== + ========================================== ---------------------------. .------------------------------------------
David Mc Auley (mca...@unix1.tcd.ie) wrote:
: There are a couple of things I have to say about all this.
: 1) Requests are part of the life blood of alt.ascii-art! How often
: has someone posted a request which has caused a new pic to be created,
: an old pic to be altered or unseen pics to be released? Sure Bob could
: reply to requests posted on the net but that wouldn't get the same
: variety of results. Personally I like to see requests and more
: particularily their followups being posted to the group.
No one except the anti-r.a-a has said that ALL requests will be
redirected. Only those which DO bog down the group: I.e. I Love You
art, birthday art, holiday art in general, calvin and hobbes, women, star
trek, and so on and on. Stuff we see asked for once a day, which has no
one creating new stuff, but everyone uploading old stuff.
If the moderater is wise, he will let SOME of the requests go through.
That way, fledgeling artists who don't KNOW about all the old stuff might
make something new.
: 2) Sure some pictures get posted often enough to make people well
: and truly sick of them. That's because they are spectacular art. We
: don't _HAVE_ to look at them each time they show up!
It's the old-stuff-reposts that I mentioned a second ago that would be
cut back.
Hmmm... Maybe I should clarify myself. I want things cut back, not
eliminated. The bush needs to be trimmed, not uprooted. If Scarecrow
intends to just remove anything off-topic without discretion, then of
course I'm against him. Scarecrow, speak up. :)
: 3) What good does sending out a FAQ do? If it's to point you
: towards ftp sites, not everyone has ftp priviledges. If it's to tell
: you how to draw them yourself, not everyone has the talent!
There are standard sets of art out there. When someone requests birthday
art, that person will likely receive a huge file stuffed with various
birthday art. When I requested ascii-women, I received e-mail from
several people that had 5-10 women apiece. I sent each post to the other
people, so that everyone else can get a fuller collection.
Which is another reason that some requests should get through.
: ++++++ In fact I voted YES but now I'm not so sure. Does anyone know
: the procedure for changing your vote?
Just vote again, I believe.
Well, now that I think about it, maybe we don't need moderation. I know
we need a r.a-a, but as for moderation..... As long as it's very LIGHT.
/>
\/< / Troy Fore
-{\\\\<>\\\\(*)XXX<:::<=====================================================-
/\< \ tfo...@st6000.sct.edu
\>
I've upped *my* standards. Up yours.
Related ASCII art in the Gallery
Explore these categories from our collection of 11,000+ artworks:
Make your own ASCII art
Turn images, text or 3D into ASCII, or draw your own – right in your browser.
About this thread.
These messages were posted publicly to the newsgroup
alt.ascii-art
in 1994 and are mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked.
The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can.
Are you one of the authors? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.
Report this message
Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.