Original Usenet thread from rec.arts.ascii, started 11 Jan 1996.
Talk-Line: Music staffs
rec.arts.ascii
· 6 messages · 11 Jan 1996 - 18 Jan 1996
On 10 Jan 1996, Bob Allison wrote: > For some time I have been using this as a sig in music newsgroups. I > is the result of many diddlings. > > |\ __3__ | > ____|) ______________|\\ ________| ____________' _| _` __| ________| __| _____ > ____| ___3_|________@'_\| _|_____| ________|___| _| _| __| |_,@ ___| __| __|__ > ___/|. __-_|___| _______| _|_____| __,@ ___|__@'_@'_@'___| |_| ___@'___| __|__ > __( ( ) _4_|___| ______@'__|____O'___| ____|____________@'_|_| _______@'___|__ > ___`|'_____|___| __________|_________| ____|_______________|_| ____________|__ > (| O' | bob...@wwa.com As a trained musician I would like to suggest that you contact your local music practitioner for a checkup. You appear to be due for your next "music refresher course". The example you give does not conform to the standards set out in the latest International College of Music "Guide to Correct Musical Composition and Note Making". Firstly, your bars do not all contain the equivalent of three crotchets: BAR No. CONTENTS BEATS __ | | | 1 O' @' @' = 3 | | 2 O' @' = 3 _3_ | | | | 3 @'@'@' @' = 2 | | | 4 @' @' @' = 3 This is only allowable in Gregorian Chant (which all modern musicians know is stupid music anyway) and some lawless varieties of Jazz, which deliberately don't conform to the prescribed forms. Secondly, it is illegal to leap over the octave in a melodic line, especially when the interval is a ninth and it is not resolved onto the octave immediately. Thirdly, the piece is written in A minor and you have failed to include a G# in the key signature. Fourthly, except for the initial minum, all the notes come from the tonic chord. Fifthly, speaking of the initial mimum, which we were, it comes on a strong beat but the pitch is not a member of the tonic, or even of the dominant chord. Fifthly, you repeat notes across the bar line without ties. Sixthly, the beginning does not sound like one and the end comes on a weak beat. Seventhly, as a somewhat minor point [since we were talking about minor things), your melody has even less melodic merit than Gregorian Chant. How about the following for slightly more meritorious compositions? The Blue Da-nube: da DA da da DUM da DA da DUM _________________________________________|) __,@____,O___________________ ||__.-.________|__|___|______,@__|__,O_____| ___|___|_|______,@__|_,O____|_|| ||_(._ ):_3____|__|___|__,@__|___|__|_____/|. __|___|_|______|___|_|_____|_|| ||___ /___4___@'__|__@___|___|___|__|____( ( )______|________|___|_|_____|_|| ||________________|______|_______|________`|'_______|____________|_______|_|| (| Original compost-ition. ___|) ________________,@________________________________________________ (|___| _______|__,@_____|___|__'O___________|___|________'@___|_'O.______|_|| ||__/|. __3___|__|__,@__|___|__|_______,@___|___|___,@___|____|_|________|_|| ||_( ( ) _4___|__|__|_______|__|_______|____|__@'___|____|____|_|________|_|| ||__`|'_______|_____|_______|__________|____|_______|_________|__________|_|| || (| | || { | -0-. | || ||______________________________________________________________|________|_|| ||__.-._______|___|_________|__,O___________|___|________,@___|_|________|_|| ||_(._ ):_3___|___|_____,@__|__|_______,@___|___|________|____|__________|_|| ||___ /___4___|__O'_____|___|__|_______|____|__O'________|____|__________|_|| (|____________|_________|___|__________|____|_________________|__________|_|| P.S. Please feel free to post whatever bits of this you feel are post-worthy. Rosemary from the Far Side = = o * l e x = = = -,. l r i u = = =I 0 \ a i l a = = = + - D ) d @ w a . = = =I 0 / n y i z = = - '` y a d o = = o * l h . .
In <4d31l5$1v...@miso.wwa.com>, Rosemary Lyndall Wemm <ros...@haywire.DIALix.COM> writes: > >On 10 Jan 1996, Bob Allison wrote: > >> For some time I have been using this as a sig in music newsgroups. I >> is the result of many diddlings. >> >> |\ __3__ | >> ____|) ______________|\\ ________| ____________' _| _` __| ________| __| _____ >> ____| ___3_|________@'_\| _|_____| ________|___| _| _| __| |_,@ ___| __| __|__ >> ___/|. __-_|___| _______| _|_____| __,@ ___|__@'_@'_@'___| |_| ___@'___| __|__ >> __( ( ) _4_|___| ______@'__|____O'___| ____|____________@'_|_| _______@'___|__ >> ___`|'_____|___| __________|_________| ____|_______________|_| ____________|__ >> (| O' | bob...@wwa.com > > [Snip] >Firstly, your bars do not all contain the equivalent of three crotchets: > > BAR No. CONTENTS BEATS > __ > | | | > 1 O' @' @' = 3 This seems to actually contain 2.5 beats (they look like semi-quavers to me) [Snip] > >Secondly, it is illegal to leap over the octave in a melodic line, >especially when the interval is a ninth and it is not resolved onto the >octave immediately. > These are the rules for (generally) writing four-part (or similar) _vocal_ harmony (simply because it is difficult to sing!). Otherwise, there's not a great problem - besides which, the rules were only originally devised so that examiners had something to assess papers by... >Thirdly, the piece is written in A minor and you have failed to include a >G# in the key signature. If it was, in fact, written in A Minor (and admittedly it does seem like it), the G# would not be in the key signature at all, but only exist as an accidental... > >Fourthly, except for the initial minum, all the notes come from the tonic >chord. > >Fifthly, speaking of the initial mimum, which we were, it comes on a >strong beat but the pitch is not a member of the tonic, or even of the >dominant chord. > [Minim] Again, if it is actually in A Minor. >Fifthly, you repeat notes across the bar line without ties. So? >Seventhly, as a somewhat minor point [since we were talking about minor >things), your melody has even less melodic merit than Gregorian Chant. I cannot disagree with this...! >How about the following for slightly more meritorious compositions? > >The Blue Da-nube: > Hmm... I've never been one for Strauss - I think I'll stick with Bob's in preference ;-) > > Original compost-ition. > Now, that's not bad. I would post something of my own, but I can't get any of it to look right in ASCII.... None of the above comments are intended to cause offense - in fact, I would be quite eager to discuss any gaps in my knowledge that are probably horribly obvious in all that I've said... Yours, striving for perfection, S Who C Wants to O Live Forever? P (Content in the knowledge that he's posting to completely the wrong Newsgroup. Ah, well...)
On Fri, 12 Jan 1996, Patrick Allen Brown wrote: > Not that I really care about this guy's sig, but your analysis of it is > a little flawed! Firstly, all the measures DO contain 3 beats, as long > as that's supposed to be a quarter note triplet in the third measure. [.........] > Secondly, it's not "illegal" to do anything in a melodic line. ...... Ah, Patrick, it was a joke. Smile :-) When I studied music we were subjected to all kinds of silly rules, which most of us later broke with abandon. My own composition does a few terrible things, too. Take a closer look at where the two lines go in relation to each other in the second and third bars. My harmony and counterpoint teacher would have marked it "wrong". [But you are mistaken about the bar lengths, though. A triplet, by definition, is three notes played in the time of two. These ones were quavers [=1/8 notes], so there really was a mistake in the number of beats in that bar.] > Or maybe he > doesn't know anything at all about music and he just thought it was a cute > signature. I suspect that he _does_ know something about music, which is why he would appreciate the rediculous analysis of his art. I also thought his artwork was pretty cute: it usually is. Rosemary. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Rosemary Lyndall Wemm Rosemary from DownUnder _--_|\ Clinical Neuro-psychologist lyn...@haywire.DIALix.oz.au Perth / \ Perth, Western Australia ber...@perth.DIALix.oz.au -->\_.--._/ ------------------- http://haywire.dialix.com/~lyndall -----------------v-
Rosemary Lyndall Wemm <ros...@haywire.DIALix.COM> writes: >On 10 Jan 1996, Bob Allison wrote: >> For some time I have been using this as a sig in music newsgroups. I >> is the result of many diddlings. >> |\ __3__ | >>____|) ______________|\\ ________| ____________' _| _` __| ________| __| _____ >>____| ___3_|________@'_\| _|_____| ________|___| _| _| __| |_,@ ___| __| __|__ >>___/|. __-_|___| _______| _|_____| __,@ ___|__@'_@'_@'___| |_| ___@'___| __|__ >>__( ( ) _4_|___| ______@'__|____O'___| ____|____________@'_|_| _______@'___|__ >>___`|'_____|___| __________|_________| ____|_______________|_| ____________|__ >> (| O' | bob...@wwa.com >As a trained musician I would like to suggest that you contact your local >music practitioner for a checkup. You appear to be due for your >next "music refresher course". >The example you give does not conform to the standards set out in the >latest International College of Music "Guide to Correct Musical >Composition and Note Making". [snip] >Thirdly, the piece is written in A minor and you have failed to include a >G# in the key signature. WHAT! Putting a g# in the key signature! Surely the "Guide" mentions that raised sevenths in minor keys are only put in as accidentals! Owen. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Owen O Byrne. [owe...@maths.tcd.ie] \ | | | / http://www.maths.tcd.ie/~owenob/owenob.html \ _-_ _-_ / Talent borrows, Genius Steals. _ (.)|(.) _ -------------------------------------------------------'//_-----^-----_\\`------
On 12 Jan 1996, The Minstrel wrote:
A detailed analysis of my "analysis" of Bob's melodic offering and
finished with:
> None of the above comments are intended to cause offense -
And none of mine were, either :-) I guess it doesn't pay to post Aussie
humour (which is highly irreverent) in a forum read by lots of Americans
:-) :-) :-) The citing of obviously fictitious Manuals of "correct
composition" should have alerted you to the true nature of the piece.
<sigh>
I was actually rather surprised that Bob chose to post my tongue-in-check
analysis at all. As the last line shows I suggested that he post only the
suitable bits, and I assumed that he would consider the melodic "analysis"
to be irrelevant. I didn't post it in my parallel posting on alt.ascii-art.
Rosemary from the Far Side
= = o * l e x
= = = -,. l r i u
= = =I 0 \ a i l a
= = = + - D ) d @ w a .
= = =I 0 / n y i z
= = - '` y a d o
= = o * l h . .
In article <4d31l5$1v...@miso.wwa.com> Rosemary Lyndall Wemm <ros...@haywire.DIALix.COM> writes: ... >P.S. Please feel free to post whatever bits of this you feel are >post-worthy. You mean "NOTEworthy", right? ______________________________________________________________________________ David M. Marks, Kennedy Development, Ltd., 600 West Hillsboro Blvd., Ste. 101, Deerfield Beach, FL 33441. Tel.: 305/421-4564 Fax: 305/421-6733 Voicemail: 407/368-7623; 312/810-1840 in Chicago dma...@gate.net, dm...@kennedyhomes.com
Related ASCII art in the Gallery
Explore these categories from our collection of 11,000+ artworks:
Make your own ASCII art
Turn images, text or 3D into ASCII, or draw your own – right in your browser.
About this thread.
These messages were posted publicly to the newsgroup
rec.arts.ascii
in 1996 and are mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked.
The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can.
Are you one of the authors? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.
Report this message
Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.