Original Usenet thread from alt.ascii-art, started 13 May 1994.
_ _ _ _ _ _ | | | |___ ___ _ __ ___| |_ / \ _ __ ___| |__ (_)_ _____ | | | / __|/ _ \ '_ \ / _ \ __| / _ \ | '__/ __| '_ \| \ \ / / _ \ | |_| \__ \ __/ | | | __/ |_ / ___ \| | | (__| | | | |\ V / __/ \___/|___/\___|_| |_|\___|\__| /_/ \_\_| \___|_| |_|_| \_/ \___|
VOTING: rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED )
alt.ascii-art
· 22 messages · 13 May 1994 - 2 Jun 1994
===================================================================
VOTING: rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED )
===================================================================
The first CFV ( Call For Votes ) has just been issued for the
proposed newsgroup :
rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED )
It is essential to be very clear on _exactly what_ you are being
asked to vote for.
You are _NOT_ simply being asked to vote for ascii-art to be moved
into the Internet mainstream newsgroups.
At present ascii-art is being carried by the newsgroup alt.ascii-art
which is free and open, _not_ a moderated group. Some postings are
also being made in the newsgroup alt.binaries.pictures.ascii.
What you _ARE_ being asked to vote for is a new MODERATED mainstream
newsgroup, rec.arts.ascii ( moderated ). ^^^^^^^^^
EFFECT on the future of ASCII-ART
Once created, there is no official way to remove either this
Moderated mainstream newsgroup, or its Moderators - either the
original moderators or their future replacements.
This extract from Ron Dippold's monthly posting entitled
"Usenet Newsgroup Creation Companion" needs careful thought:
> Q: How about getting rid of the moderator?
> A: There is _no_ official way to get rid of a moderator
> without their consent! Even if they turn out to be a bum
> who never does anything, you can't replace them.
If you favour moderation of ascii-art and decide to vote for
rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED) please realise that it will then be very
difficult to establish later an _unmoderated_ mainstream newsgroup
for ascii-art if a mainstream _moderated_ group is created.
EFFECT on the EXISTING newsgroup ALT.ASCII-ART
The establishment of a MODERATED mainstream group for ascii-art will
inevitably have an effect on the present newsgroup ALT.ASCII-ART
which has already had phenomenal success as a new newsgroup.
All material rejected from the new MODERATED group and all
dissatisfactions with that MODERATED group will inevitably get
dumped into ALT.ASCII-ART, to the existing newsgroup's detriment.
Also, a _mainstream_ group, either moderated _or_ unmoderated, has no
provision for all the ascii-art postings which require a binary
format, like vt animations containing escape codes; executable
programs; ansi pictures and animations; and large files and
collections which call for compression and archive format - which
changes them to binary files.
All this material will again have to be "dumped" somewhere in the alt.
hierarchy. It will not be acceptable in the mainstream group.
STATUS of the newsgroup ALT.ASCII-ART
In just a few months, since its first appearance in September 1993,
the existing newsgroup, ALT.ASCII-ART, has achieved a Site
propagation level of 44% and an estimated current readership of
84,000. It has a high signal-to-noise ratio and it is growing
rapidly. It is a free, open and unmoderated newsgroup.
Unfortunately not all users of ALT.ASCII-ART are content with the
existing newsgroup and wish to have ASCII-ART moderated to exclude
postings they prefer not to see. These users are the proponents for
the new newsgroup rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED ).
THINK CAREFULLY BEFORE YOU VOTE !
The estimated 84,000 readers of the newsgroup alt.ascii-art ( and
others who intend to vote ) should think very carefully about
which way they should vote on this proposal for a MODERATED newsgroup.
The proponents of the new group have announced, in the CFV, that
they will be seeking votes from the Figlet Mailing List:
CFV> After this CFV appears on news.announce.newgroups, it will
CFV> be sent to the Figlet mailing list maintained by Ian Chai,
CFV> and to Bob Allison's list of users and fans of ASCII art.
This is a legitimate tactic to gain votes from users with a vested
interest in having unwanted material excluded from the newsgroup
before they receive news. The ultimate danger is that these mailing
list users will exert undue influence on Moderators of a moderated
newsgroup to exclude certain postings sent to the newsgroup.
-------------- Extract from the CFV ( Call For Votes ) -------------
HOW TO VOTE
Send MAIL to: vot...@dogwood.com
Just Replying should work if you are not reading this on a mailing list.
Your mail message should contain one of the following statements:
I vote YES on rec.arts.ascii
I vote NO on rec.arts.ascii
You may also ABSTAIN in place of YES/NO - this will not affect the
outcome. Anything else may be rejected by the automatic vote
counting program. The votetaker will respond to your received
ballots with a personal acknowledgement by mail - if you do not
receive one within several days, try again. It's your
responsibility to make sure your vote is registered correctly.
One vote counted per person, no more than one per account. Addresses
and votes of all voters will be published in the final voting
results list. Votes from system accounts and anonymous votes cannot
be accepted.
Votes must be received by 23:59:59 UTC, 30 May 1994.
-------------------- End of extract from CFV -----------------------
==========================================
Think carefully....then vote carefully !
==========================================
.
/:\
|:|
|:|
|:| *_ _ _ _ _ _ _ *
|:| __ | `_' `-' `_' `-' `_' `-' `_'|
,_|:|_, / ) | |
(Oo / _I_ | LONG LIVE alt.ascii-art |
+\ \ || __| ^ | | ^
\ \||___| | | Free & Unmoderated | |
\ /.:.\-\ | (*) |_ _ _ _ _ _ _ | \^/ |
|.:. /-----\ | _<">_ | `_' `-' `_' `-' `_' `-' `_'| _(#)_ |
|___| oOo | o+o \a/ \0 0/ \a/ (=)
/ |<a.a-a>| 0'\a-a/\/ \/\a-a/`0
|_____\ : / /_^_\ | | /_^_\
| | \ \:/ || || | | || ||
| | | | d|_|b_T____________________________T_d|_|b
\ / | \___ / /
/ | \_____\ / /
`-' / /
________________________/ /___________
Votes must be received by 23:59:59 UTC, 30 May 1994.
Bye,
In article <Col...@equinox.gen.nz>
Col...@equinox.gen.nz (Colin Douthwaite) writes:
}===================================================================
} VOTING: rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED )
}===================================================================
}The first CFV ( Call For Votes ) has just been issued for the
}proposed newsgroup :
} rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED )
}It is essential to be very clear on _exactly what_ you are being
}asked to vote for.
}
}You are _NOT_ simply being asked to vote for ascii-art to be moved
}into the Internet mainstream newsgroups.
}
}At present ascii-art is being carried by the newsgroup alt.ascii-art
}which is free and open, _not_ a moderated group. Some postings are
}also being made in the newsgroup alt.binaries.pictures.ascii.
}
}What you _ARE_ being asked to vote for is a new MODERATED mainstream
}newsgroup, rec.arts.ascii ( moderated ). ^^^^^^^^^
}
}EFFECT on the future of ASCII-ART
}
(deleted a lot of drivel on moderated newsgroups rules... )
}
}Also, a _mainstream_ group, either moderated _or_ unmoderated, has no
}provision for all the ascii-art postings which require a binary
}format, like vt animations containing escape codes; executable
}programs; ansi pictures and animations; and large files and
}collections which call for compression and archive format - which
}changes them to binary files.
}
Absolutely untrue: the objections to binary files in most of the
picture groups are due to size, not content, since they are uuencoded
anyway; the average uuencoded post in alt.ascii-art, is about 60k,
much smaller than anything in the binaries groups (that is **uuencoded**
size; raw size would probably be about 40K)
}All this material will again have to be "dumped" somewhere in the alt.
}hierarchy. It will not be acceptable in the mainstream group.
}
yeah, right?!? :-)
}
}
}STATUS of the newsgroup ALT.ASCII-ART
}
}In just a few months, since its first appearance in September 1993,
}the existing newsgroup, ALT.ASCII-ART, has achieved a Site
}propagation level of 44% and an estimated current readership of
}84,000.
Shows how popular ascii art can become.
} It has a high signal-to-noise ratio and it is growing
}rapidly. It is a free, open and unmoderated newsgroup.
}
Unfortunately, untrue: unfortunately, the perception of signal-to-noise
ratio is very subjective; imho, it is quite low...
}Unfortunately not all users of ALT.ASCII-ART are content with the
}existing newsgroup and wish to have ASCII-ART moderated to exclude
}postings they prefer not to see. These users are the proponents for
}the new newsgroup rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED ).
}
Yes, that is true, they would rather not see the umpteenth repeatition
of the umpteenth request for a cute .sig; the umpteenth request for
an ftp site, the umpteenth request for roses, flowers, starships,
etc., etc.. followed by the umpteenth instance of the same (by now
boring) repeats of pix which everybody has seen before except for the
person who started the thread in the first place.
Instead, the moderator would answer those requests
directly by sending them a canned file (probably the Faq or a subfile).
The rationale for this philosophy is that the signal to noise ratio in
alt.ascii-art is very low, and moderation would do lots to improve it!
Besides, let's face it; it looks like most of usenet will be moderated
in the next few years...
}
}THINK CAREFULLY BEFORE YOU VOTE !
}
I agree: do you ****really**** want to see another request for
a cute .sig???????? How about another three-page rose???
(deletia...)
} CFV> After this CFV appears on news.announce.newgroups, it will
} CFV> be sent to the Figlet mailing list maintained by Ian Chai,
} CFV> and to Bob Allison's list of users and fans of ASCII art.
}
}This is a legitimate tactic to gain votes from users with a vested
}interest in having unwanted material excluded from the newsgroup
}before they receive news. The ultimate danger is that these mailing
}list users will exert undue influence on Moderators of a moderated
}newsgroup to exclude certain postings sent to the newsgroup.
}
Natch! You are being paranoid, just as I was: the people doing
the moderation are some of the ***most*** active people in alt.ascii-art,
who have repeatedly posted samples of their art: they definitely will
approve any post with merit.
}
}-------------- Extract from the CFV ( Call For Votes ) -------------
}
}HOW TO VOTE
}
}Send MAIL to: vot...@dogwood.com
}Just Replying should work if you are not reading this on a mailing list.
}
}Your mail message should contain one of the following statements:
} I vote YES on rec.arts.ascii
} I vote NO on rec.arts.ascii
}
}You may also ABSTAIN in place of YES/NO - this will not affect the
}outcome. Anything else may be rejected by the automatic vote
}counting program. The votetaker will respond to your received
(deletia.......)
}Votes must be received by 23:59:59 UTC, 30 May 1994.
}Bye,
Since my ascii art is very bad, here is a sample from the proposed moderator:
From bob...@gagme.wwa.com Fri May 13 09:12:06 1994
___ _ ____ _ ___
/ \__/ \__/ \__/ \__/ \ "Hey Rocky!
| _|@ @ __ | Watch me pull some intelligence
\________/ | | \________/ out of the InterNet!"
__/ _/ "But that trick never works."
/) (o _/ "This time for sure."
\____/ bob...@gagme.wwa.com
I must admit, I was sceptical also, but the comments above helped
turn me around. I voted YES and ask you to vote YES for rec.arts.ascii also.
--
Michael Rothstein (Kent State U)| Any similarity between Kent State's opinions
(rot...@mcs.kent.edu) | and my opinions is strictly coincidential.
The problem with some lawyers is that they don't know the difference between
"legal" and "ethical". And, they're the ones who make the laws.
I vote NO on rec.arts.ascii -- ========================================================================== James Evan Jacoby | "I'm so confident I'm sane." -> Gordon gal...@loreli.ftl.fl.us | "I'd go out of my mind but for you." Sumner ==========================================================================
>From: Col...@equinox.gen.nz (Colin Douthwaite) >It is essential to be very clear on _exactly what_ you are being >asked to vote for. No one is trying to hide anything. Yes, rec.arts.ascii will be a moderated group. That will reduce the amount of traffic waste due to repeated posts, often requested material, flames and other items that have no connection with ASCII art. >EFFECT on the future of ASCII-ART >If you favour moderation of ascii-art and decide to vote for >rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED) please realise that it will then be >very difficult to establish later an _unmoderated_ mainstream >newsgroup for ascii-art if a mainstream _moderated_ group is >created. The goal of rec.arts.ascii, as far as I understand it, is to increase the propagation of ASCII art. That is in fact helping its future, not hurting it. Further more, like I have said during the RFD period there are only two ways to increase the percentage of related posts within a group: 1) increase the amount of related posts, and 2) decrease the amount of unrelated posts. The only sure way to currently implement number 2 is by moderation. Based on what I know of the proposed moderator there is no reason to believe that he would remove posts that are related to the subject matter. The only people that stand to lose are the would be flamers and associates. >EFFECT on the EXISTING newsgroup ALT.ASCII-ART >The establishment of a MODERATED mainstream group for ascii-art >will inevitably have an effect on the present newsgroup >ALT.ASCII-ART which has already had phenomenal success as a new >newsgroup. The phenomal success you refer to is probably due to the high dedication of several now well known contributors of alt.ascii-art that go out of their way to respond to requests for pictures or to provide needed information to users. In my opinion, the proposed moderator (Bob Allison) falls within that category of individuals. >All material rejected from the new MODERATED group and all >dissatisfactions with that MODERATED group will inevitably get >dumped into ALT.ASCII-ART, to the existing newsgroup's detriment. "All material" ? That seems highly exaggerated. Why would a post about "MAKE MONEY FAST" end up in alt.ascii-art after removal from rec.arts.ascii? Why would the removal of a flame concerning a post on rec.arts.ascii end up in alt.ascii-art? They might, but if they do it will be because the author wishes them to be displayed there and not because the moderator wishes it. There is a very good chance that the "garbage" will go nowhere after it gets rejected from rec.arts.ascii. >STATUS of the newsgroup ALT.ASCII-ART >In just a few months, since its first appearance in September >1993, the existing newsgroup, ALT.ASCII-ART, has achieved a Site >propagation level of 44% and an estimated current readership of >84,000. It has a high signal-to-noise ratio and it is growing >rapidly. It is a free, open and unmoderated newsgroup. True. See my comments above on the "phenomal success". Unfortunately signal-to-noise ratio is subjective. Alt.ascii-art has its share of multiple requests for the same item, duplicated posts in close succesion, some unrelated material, and the occassional flame which attracts more of the same. There is considerable room for improvement. BTW, if all the "noisy" posts were removed there would be no need for a signal-to-noise ratio! I can see why some people could go crazy over that, after all they would have to divide by 0 to calculate it :-) >Unfortunately not all users of ALT.ASCII-ART are content with the >existing newsgroup and wish to have ASCII-ART moderated to exclude >postings they prefer not to see. These users are the proponents >for the new newsgroup rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED ). Another highly exaggerated comment. I for one am happy with what alt.ascii-art offers since it is currently the best group for ASCII art on the Usenet. Nonetheless, if I were given the choice between a group that contains ASCII art along with many "junk posts" and a group that contains ASCII art with no "junk posts", I would prefer the second one. It only makes sense: the less junk that circulates in the group, the less time I lose discarding it and the more time I have to do more important things like creating other ASCII pictures. Is this too hard to understand? >THINK CAREFULLY BEFORE YOU VOTE ! >The estimated 84,000 readers of the newsgroup alt.ascii-art ( and >others who intend to vote ) should think very carefully about >which way they should vote on this proposal for a MODERATED >newsgroup. Agreed. Everyone is invited to look at both sides of the story and make their own decision. After all, it is a democratic process. >The proponents of the new group have announced, in the CFV, that >they will be seeking votes from the Figlet Mailing List: >This is a legitimate tactic to gain votes from users with a vested >interest in having unwanted material excluded from the newsgroup >before they receive news. The ultimate danger is that these >mailing list users will exert undue influence on Moderators of a >moderated newsgroup to exclude certain postings sent to the >newsgroup. Oh boy, here we ago again. Would you be trying to scare people off by any chance? The rules that apply to CFV's allow the use of mailing lists related to the subject matter so long as they are stated in the CFV (looks like that has been done). As you are well aware, FIGLET allows the creation of ascii text in various fonts. That is very relevant to ASCII art since many drawings also include text. You would have had all the reasons in the world to complain about the list if it had been completely un-related, but such is not the case. I voted YES to rec.arts.ascii and I sincerely believe that if the group gets created, your opinions about it will be shown to be completely incorrect. -- Normand Veilleux As a "long term" contributing artist to nve...@emr1.emr.ca alt.ascii-art, I hereby declare that ---------------------------- rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED) has my support.
perhaps many of the concerns of those who dislike the idea of rec.arts.ascii being moderated would be met by the creation of a sister rec.arts.ascii.d unmoderated for discussion of ascii rather than posting it. All this and more from... Cra...@brown.edu Never attribute to malice that which could be adequately explained by stupidity.
Col...@equinox.gen.nz (Colin Douthwaite) writes in news.groups: |Requests do not bother me at all. I believe that requests, reposts |and even arguments have a valuable place in an ascii-art newsgroup - |I don't want it sanitised by moderators - but you do - OK we differ. Then if the new group passes, you should start right away at getting a companian rec.arts.ascii.d (UNModerated) group started. Or hope that both groups continue, much like the current rec.arts.erotica/alt.sex.stories split of material. |> Besides, let's face it; it looks like most of usenet will be |> moderated in the next few years... | |In the words of that classic line by John Wayne: | | "That'll be the day !" Actually, he's right. It's being forced on groups by people like S*rd*r Arg*c, the Green Card lawyers, and the flood of newbies who refuse to read the FAQ or even the group before posting questions that end with "oh and mail me since I'm not gonna bother looking here for answers." -- -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Alan Coopersmith Internet: ala...@ocf.berkeley.edu U.C. Berkeley Open Computing Facility Bitnet: alanc@ucbocf
In article <Col...@equinox.gen.nz> ">" and Michael Rothstein (rot...@Monkey.mcs.kent.edu) "> >" wrote: [...] > > Yes, that is true, they would rather not see the umpteenth > > repetition of the umpteenth request for a cute .sig; the umpteenth > > request for... [...] > Exactly what do you really find wrong with this newsgroup, except > the requests and repeats, which are the main motivation for this > proposal for a new moderated group ? [...] > You are surely not suggesting that a picture should only ever be > posted once, and once only, in a newsgroup ? This is an interesting question. There are many reasons someone would ask for or want to see repeats of ascii art. One is that many sites expire articles after some usually too small a period. I wouldn't be surprised if the alt hierarchy and/or graphics related groups would be the ones with the short expiration periods. How often would art be replayed into the moderated group? Do you (the generic y'all) plan to maintain an ftp site for the existing ascii-art and use the moderated group to premier the new stuff? BTW, I looked around for the RFD, but it has long since expired on this site. ----- Rene' /* The opinions expressed herein are mine, and not necessarily my employer's */
Paul Fawcett (pau...@manor.demon.co.uk) wrote: > For anyone who is still not sure what this means, let me repeat > Normand's enlightened words once again: >> repeated posts, often requested material, flames and other items ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ >> that have no connection with ASCII art. ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ So just because _you_ have seen something already it should not appear in the newsgroup again ? What is so enlightening about that concept ? > That's all the moderator is going to cut, NOTHING ELSE! Dream on ! What will you say if he cuts one of _your_ posts ? > Vote YES for rec.arts.ascii. Please do it today! But remember to change your vote to NO tomorrow :-) Bye,
In article <2rgtgb$kj...@agate.berkeley.edu>, Alan Coopersmith <ala...@ocf.berkeley.edu> wrote: >Col...@equinox.gen.nz (Colin Douthwaite) writes in news.groups: >|Requests do not bother me at all. I believe that requests, reposts >|and even arguments have a valuable place in an ascii-art newsgroup - >|I don't want it sanitised by moderators - but you do - OK we differ. > >Then if the new group passes, you should start right away at getting a >companian rec.arts.ascii.d (UNModerated) group started. Or hope that >both groups continue, much like the current rec.arts.erotica/alt.sex.stories >split of material. > >|> Besides, let's face it; it looks like most of usenet will be >|> moderated in the next few years... >| >|In the words of that classic line by John Wayne: >| >| "That'll be the day !" > >Actually, he's right. It's being forced on groups by people like S*rd*r >Arg*c, the Green Card lawyers, and the flood of newbies who refuse to read >the FAQ or even the group before posting questions that end with "oh and >mail me since I'm not gonna bother looking here for answers." Very true. The handwriting is on the wallet. It costs a lot to propogate waste. In the future, we'll either have moderation thrust upon us, or it will be set up so every email, post, ftp, telnet, gopher, or whatever you do, will couse funds to be transfered out of your bank occount. To avoid having heavy handed moderation thrust upon us, we need to figure out rules for minimal moderation, ways to elect a moderator before the group is voted on, and ways to replace a moderator. -- ======= ====== ======= ======= ====== ====== ======= ======= === === === /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// ------- --- ------- ------- ------ --- ------- --- --- --- --- --- /// /// /// /// ////// /// /// ////// /// /// /// /// /// ======= ====== === === === === ====== ====== === === ======= ===========
>From: Col...@equinox.gen.nz (Colin Douthwaite) >Paul Fawcett (pau...@manor.demon.co.uk) wrote: > >> For anyone who is still not sure what this means, let me repeat >> Normand's enlightened words once again: >>> repeated posts, often requested material, flames and other items ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ >>> that have no connection with ASCII art. > ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ > >So just because _you_ have seen something already it should not >appear in the newsgroup again ? It has nothing to do with _him_; it has to do with _us_. Every time someone re-posts a picture _we_ all see it again. I have seen instances where the same picture was posted 5 or 6 times in one week, and another where the same picture was posted 10 to 12 times in a month. I call that unnecessary waste of bandwidth and of everyone's time and money. BTW, no one ever said that "ALL REPEATED POSTS WILL BE FOREVER FORBIDEN." There is quite a difference between seeing a picture posted once a month and once every couple of days! One is acceptable the other is nothing but waste. Asking people to be reasonable about it just does not work. >What is so enlightening about that concept ? Whether it's enlightening or not is besides the point. The point is, the moderator proposes to reduce the amount of "junk" posts that float around. I am in favour of such actions. >> That's all the moderator is going to cut, NOTHING ELSE! > >Dream on ! >What will you say if he cuts one of _your_ posts ? That all depends on the type of post: Moderator cuts | I say: one of my: | ===================|======================= newly created | He's an idiot. pictures | -------------------|----------------------- a picture already | I would accept that posted this week | as waste management. (RE: a repeat) | -------------------|----------------------- request | It's OK if he replied | with what I wanted or | told me where I could | find it. -------------------|----------------------- flame | He prevented the flame | from attracting other | undesirable posts (waste | management plus defusing | of potentially explosive | situation). -------------------|----------------------- MAKE MONEY FAST | He prevented me from post | being attacked by tons | of flames (protection of | gullible user and waste | management). -------------------|----------------------- >> Vote YES for rec.arts.ascii. Please do it today! >But remember to change your vote to NO tomorrow :-) Hmm, an intimidating tactic perhaps! Dream on ! -- Normand Veilleux As a "long term" contributing artist to nve...@emr1.emr.ca alt.ascii-art, I hereby declare that ---------------------------- rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED) has my support.
In article <Nve...@emr1.emr.ca> on Fri, 20 May 1994 22:21:02 GMT, Normand Veilleux (Nve...@emr1.emr.ca) made the following noteworthy contribution to the highly esteemed collected works of rec.humor: : BTW, no one ever said that "ALL REPEATED POSTS WILL BE FOREVER FORBIDEN." A good thing, too. -- Captain Nitpick
>From: eva...@pairgain.com (Bill Evans) >In article <Nve...@emr1.emr.ca> on Fri, 20 May 1994 22:21:02 GMT, >Normand Veilleux (Nve...@emr1.emr.ca) made the following noteworthy contribution >to the highly esteemed collected works of rec.humor: > >: BTW, no one ever said that "ALL REPEATED POSTS WILL BE FOREVER FORBIDEN." > >A good thing, too. > >-- Captain Nitpick Aye, aye, captain. (big wave :-) I see you are having a whale of a time. :-) Something seems rather fishy about your comment. I can't sea the joke! Would you mind stepping ashore and explaining yourself? I have a good provision of rum in my cellar. -- Normand Veilleux As a "long term" contributing artist to nve...@emr1.emr.ca alt.ascii-art, I hereby declare that ---------------------------- rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED) has my support.
Heya,
REC or ALT? May I take up the position of the neutral undecided? I have
several arguments for both sides:
For REC.A.A:
o All of the major artists on this channel seem to be for it. I am in favor of
keeping them happy, so that they'll continue to post, and I can continue to
grab their stuff for my library.
o It'd be nice to have someone who could keep track of the credits for drawings
for people who are concerned about being credited. (Personally, I only care
when I see my stuff w/ someone else's name)
o Scarecrow puts a lot into this channel already; I'd be interested in what he'd
do with it.
o Scarecrow needs something else to do besides making new .sig files for
himself. :)
o I admit, I tire easily of the nazi-sun logo thread.
For ALT.A-A:
o We already have a low signal-to-noise here; and it is very obvious what the
noise is. It's that stuff without pictures. I can junk those without
pausing.
o I like seeing *all* of the requests, multiple or not. It gives me an idea of
what people want.
o There is very little that I would consider TRUE garbage on this channel, like
the famous MAKE MONEY FAST. And if we didn't know about scumwaffles like
these, who would there be to write the scumwaffle's sys-op, to narc on how
he's abusing internet? :-)
o Multiple posts of the same pic are kinda nice, since sometimes I decide that
I *do* want a copy of a pic, after I have hit return. (Example: Aww, gee. I
really *could* use a pic of Meriday. Wonder if I'll ever see her again?) :)
In short, I'm not unhappy with alt.a-a, but I don't think that Bob moderating
the group would be such a bad thing, either. (Call me Mr. Wishy-Washy)
/^^^\ /--------------------------------\
(| "o" |) | To vote, mail vot...@dogwood.com |
( --- ) ........\--------------------------------/
~| |~ .-~~-.
/ \ ,|`-__-'|
/(. .)\___5| |
(<| . |`---3| |
`w x ) `| |
|| || `-__-'
() ()
|| || -Ian
ooO Ooo
--
ia...@venus.engr.ucdavis.edu | | UCD Mech & Aero, #02404; Davis, CA 95616
---------------------------' `------------------------------------------
=========================== + ==========================================
---------------------------. .------------------------------------------
Hee do you know some countries also thought of the disadvantages of free speach? Moderation is the beginning of a trent which will destroy the net news as we know it if not stopped. Ich habe es nicht gewuBt ? Yeah right.. LS.
>>From: eva...@pairgain.com (Bill Evans) > >>In article <Nve...@emr1.emr.ca> on Fri, 20 May 1994 22:21:02 GMT, >>Normand Veilleux (Nve...@emr1.emr.ca) made the following noteworthy contribution >>to the highly esteemed collected works of rec.humor: >> >>: BTW, no one ever said that "ALL REPEATED POSTS WILL BE FOREVER FORBIDEN." >> >>A good thing, too. >> >>-- Captain Nitpick For those of you, like me, who were wondering what this post was all about, I received an explanation from the captain. It was an obscure way of saying that FORBIDEN was mispelled. He offered an apology since he noticed that my first language was most probably French. -- Normand Veilleux As a "long term" contributing artist to nve...@emr1.emr.ca alt.ascii-art, I hereby declare that ---------------------------- rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED) has my support.
Bob Allison (bob...@gagme.wwa.com) wrote: : > : >|> Besides, let's face it; it looks like most of usenet will be : >|> moderated in the next few years... : >| : >|In the words of that classic line by John Wayne: : >| : >| "That'll be the day !" : > : >Actually, he's right. It's being forced on groups by people like S*rd*r : >Arg*c, the Green Card lawyers, and the flood of newbies who refuse to read : >the FAQ or even the group before posting questions that end with "oh and : >mail me since I'm not gonna bother looking here for answers." > Very true. The handwriting is on the wallet. It costs a lot to > propogate waste. In the future, we'll either have moderation > thrust upon us, or it will be set up so every email, post, ftp, > telnet, gopher, or whatever you do, will couse funds to be > transfered out of your bank occount. This is just your wishful thinking, not reality. Moderation will only be thrust upon us if net users allow more and more Moderators to be elected and with no way of getting rid of them either !! Some of us are _already_ on "user pays" systems. In New Zealand all users are charged for all traffic, both incoming and outgoing, in addition to the connection fees to the access site. I understand that Australia is soon to introduce a similar system. Astonishing as it may sound the traffic charge has just been reduced here from $15 per megabyte to $10 per megabyte because of some improved efficiencies in the distribution system. Great rejoicing from all NZ users. :-) Moderators are not going to stop the gradual introduction of user- pays systems. In my opinion Internet is a much better place without Moderators except for very exceptional administrative and/or technical newsgroups. Tell you what - I don't want to pay one cent to have Moderators elected to Internet newsgroups. Moderators get their reward by the status they achieve as net.personalities. > To avoid having heavy handed moderation thrust upon us, we need > to figure out rules for minimal moderation, ways to elect a > moderator before the group is voted on, and ways to replace a > moderator. Having read all your postings for several months in alt.ascii-art, and whilst acknowledging your valuable contributions to this newsgroup, I am gradually coming to the conclusion that you are more interested in Moderating and Net Administration than in ASCII- ART. Your comment above is just one illustration of what I mean. Also once you are elected there is no guarantee that you will not become heavy-handed. Pre-election promises are one thing, post-election realities are usually very different. I note that provision for the means to remove the Moderators from the proposed newsgroup, rec.arts.ascii (moderated), were not included in the Charter. Why not ? They could have been. It seems extraordinary to me that Internet users allow Moderators to be elected as an integral part of a new newsgroup and provides no official way of removing a Moderator afterwards. Someone pulled the wool over people's eyes sometime somewhere. I hope they weren't using New Zealand or Australian wool :-) Bye,
>Some of us are _already_ on "user pays" systems. In New Zealand all >users are charged for all traffic, both incoming and outgoing, in >addition to the connection fees to the access site. I understand >that Australia is soon to introduce a similar system. Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaat. Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!! Geez I hope not! Actually, it may have already started. Just 3 days ago we were banned from all FTP/telnet/talk activity. That sux! >Astonishing as it may sound the traffic charge has just been reduced >here from $15 per megabyte to $10 per megabyte because of some $10 per meg!!!??? Wow! If I were paying that, I'd be asking for moderators ;). >In my opinion Internet is a much better place without Moderators >except for very exceptional administrative and/or technical >newsgroups. >Tell you what - I don't want to pay one cent to have Moderators >elected to Internet newsgroups. Moderators get their reward by the >status they achieve as net.personalities. >newsgroup, I am gradually coming to the conclusion that you are >more interested in Moderating and Net Administration than in ASCII-ART. Eeek. Without wishing to speak for Bob, I know for a fact that he didn't jump at the chance to moderate. There was a search conducted to try and find someone willing and able, and when no one was found, Bob was almost "pushed" into it. Even then he had to think through the feasability (sp). Big sigs are one thing, but that above comment is another. Row.
Moderation is censorship. -=Gabriel=-
In article bf...@deadmin.ucsd.edu, gve...@ucsd.edu (Gabriel Velasco) writes: >Moderation is censorship. > >-=Gabriel=- USENET is not, and never will be, a democracy. USENET is not fair. Those two gems of wisdome were pulled (if my rapidly fading memory serves) from Zen and the Art of the Internet. One should remember them before they start to make comments about censorship, or fairness, or many other things. I don't like it much either (that it's not fair) but then again, whose fair is the one that get's used? Mine? Yours? Scarecrows? I figure most everyone is lucky to even have this chance to vote.... --- Vlad_K-Fuchida - BT3056 MUSE, 321st ComGuard Grenadiers | PGP Public MagLev - Shadowrun MUSH, Constructor | key available Silver Samurai - UVic Oggsquad (Summer INL hopefuls) | via finger Krenn - Shire of Ramsgaard, Kingdom of An Tir, SCA |--------------- GE: d- -p+ c++++ l u+ e+ m--- s++/ n h* f+ g+ w+ t++ r++ y+
>From: gve...@ucsd.edu (Gabriel Velasco) >Moderation is censorship. Is it really ? Let's assume that you and I are in the newspaper business. We receive hundreds and thousands of news pieces every week, but since we have a limited budget and since we cannot print everything anyway, we define a set of rules that help us reduce that huge amount of information down to a more manageable size. By reducing the amount of information, we are choosing what we think is representative of what our clients like to read. Of course, the clients' input is welcomed. Is that moderation or censorship ? To me that's moderation. Now, let's assume that before we are allowed to distribute this information to the public we are forced, by law for example, to have it approved by an organization of some sort. Non compliance could mean that we would be put out of business, so we reluctantly submit the information we selected for approval. This organization also has a set of rules that it uses to reduce the amount of information. In this case though, the organization is purposefully eliminating information that we think our clients would be interested in seeing. Furthermore, the clients' input is totally irrelevent to them. Now, is that moderation or censorship ? This, IMO qualifies as censorship. I don't have a clear cut definition of what moderation is or what censorship is, but I agree that they both eliminate something. IMO though, they do not eliminate the same things and they do not eliminate them for the same reasons. Hence, moderation is not the same as censorship. BTW, what do you call it when a site cuts access or refuses to grant access to a particular Usenet group ? Moderation or censorship ? Why is it that some people allow _entire_ newsgroups to be unaccessible without complaining, yet _vehemently_ protest when someone proposes to eliminate even a _small_ portion of the information that circulates in a newsgroup ? Are those people just overreacting or what ? Don't they realize that moderation is all around us _today_ in our free society ? Every newspaper, radio station, magazine, TV news program, etc, serve their clients by "filtering" information with their own set of rules before distributing it. This enables them to guarantee their clients a high level of cohesiveness among the various pieces of information contained in their "products". We then choose the products or "packages" of information that we feel will meet our current needs. Notice that this process of information distribution automatically takes care of labelling the information and ensuring that it gets distributed only by channels that have clients that are interested in seeing that particular type of information. Some of you might be saying, "well, that's exactly what the Usenet does too." Not so! In the case of the Usenet, anybody can post anything in any newsgroup they want, at anytime, whether the "information" belongs there or not (with the exception of moderated groups of course). _Quite_ a difference! In the case of the "regular media", there is a high level of order because of inherent controls, while in the case of the Usenet there is a continuous motion between order and disorder due to the free-for-all approach. Moderation is a tool by which order can be ensured in a newsgroup, irrelevant of whether the attitudes and behaviours of the set of users present were conducive to order or disorder prior to moderation being applied. Many people fear moderation in cyberspace, yet they don't appear to mind it at all in real life. Why ? -- Normand Veilleux As a "long term" contributing artist to nve...@emr1.emr.ca alt.ascii-art, I hereby declare that ---------------------------- rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED) has my support.
Moderation? I say Nay, I have no idea whatt the moderator would
be like. + the urge to use their own personal taste/feelings
in 'editing' this type of group is a little large and not
worth it. If you could truthful guarentee me that all they'd
do is remove illrelevent and repost posts, than I'd probably
back it, but that can't be done.
--
______________________
/ \$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$\ <\ /\
( \$$$$$$$$$k\;\&j$$$$$$) /\ | \|\ /\ < \ /\ /\
|\ \$$$$$$$,' `^<$$$| / \| | |/ \| \| | |
|$$\ \$$$;' __n, `:$| | \ | | | | | | \_| | |
|$$$$\ \$$jT$$$$i. ,$$$| |\ \| | | | | __| | |
|$$$$$\ \$$$$$$$;J$$$| | \ | | | | | | | | | |
|$$$$$$$\ \$$$$$$$$$$| \ /| | | | | | | /
\$$$$$$$$\ \$$$$$$$/ \/ \| / \/ \/ \/ | /
\$$$$$$$$$\ \$$$$/ </ </
\$$$$$$$$$$\ \$/
\$$$$$$$$$$$\ / ran...@netcom.com
\$$$$$$$$$$$$\ / Dragons Eye Publishing - Totally Fictional
\$$$$$$$$$$/
\$$$$$$/ "It's easy to amuse him, but when he laughs...
\$$/ watch your back."
In article <2s2tkd$bf...@deadmin.ucsd.edu>, gve...@ucsd.edu (Gabriel Velasco) writes: - Moderation is censorship. Is it now? Where have I heard that before? If you believe that then perhaps you should tell the 152 newsgroups I have listed as moderated in my "newsgroups" file. I'm sure the folks who post there will be surprised to find out they are suppressed, prohibited and downtrodden. -- Dave Ratcliffe vogon1!frackit!dav...@cse.psu.edu Harrisburg, Pa.
Related ASCII art in the Gallery
Explore these categories from our collection of 11,000+ artworks:
Make your own ASCII art
Turn images, text or 3D into ASCII, or draw your own – right in your browser.
About this thread.
These messages were posted publicly to the newsgroup
alt.ascii-art
in 1994 and are mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked.
The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can.
Are you one of the authors? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.
Report this message
Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.